By: Garfield L. Angus
November 20, 2026
Across the streets of Kingston, Bridgetown, Port of Spain, and the broader Global South, a vital political conversation is taking root among everyday citizens, the “massive” whose livelihoods, freedoms, and futures hang in the balance of great-power politics.
At the center of this debate is a stark choice between two competing visions of the twenty-first century. On one side stands the resurgence of unilateral strongman politics, dubbed the “Donroe Doctrine”—a modern retooling of the nineteenth-century Monroe Doctrine championed by President Donald Trump.
On the other stands the urgent, moral, and practical plea of Barbadian Prime Minister Mia Amor Mottley, who has consistently urged the international community to defend, reform, and expand a genuinely equitable rules-based international order.
For the ordinary people of the Caribbean and the wider developing world, rejecting the Donroe Doctrine in favor of Mottley’s vision is not merely an abstract diplomatic preference. It is a matter of survival, dignity, and sovereignty.
The Peril of the “Donroe Doctrine”
Coined in early 2025 and later embraced by President Trump following the January 2026 U.S. military raid in Venezuela that deposed Nicolás Maduro, the Donroe Doctrine asserts unchecked American dominance across the Western Hemisphere.
Built on militarised regional security, punitive trade tariffs, and overt territorial ambition—including threats to annex Greenland and reclaim control over the Panama Canal—this doctrine treats the Americas not as a community of sovereign nations, but as an exclusive sphere of influence. To the massive, this playbook looks painfully familiar. It echoes an era of gunboat diplomacy where the powerful dictate terms and smaller nations are expected to fall in line or face economic and military coercion.
When international boundaries, trade agreements, and national sovereignty can be overridden by unilateral force or economic blackmail, no small state is truly secure. Furthermore, normalising territorial coercion in the Western Hemisphere sets a dangerous global precedent. If Washington claims the right to dominate its neighbors by force, other global powers will inevitably claim the exact same license in Eastern Europe, the South China Sea, or Africa.
The result is a fractured, hyper-militarized world where the resources desperately needed for healthcare, education, and infrastructure are swallowed by endless conflict and geopolitical rivalry.
Mia Mottley’s Case for a Rules-Based Order
Against this tide of unilateralism, Prime Minister Mia Mottley has emerged as one of the clearest voices for the Global South. Addressing the United Nations General Assembly and global forums throughout 2025 and 2026, Mottley has warned world leaders that abandoning international law invites chaos.
As she stated bluntly to the General Assembly, “The law of the jungle does not guarantee any of us a future or a liveable planet”. In the absence of binding global rules, she noted, small states are reduced to “children on a playground running from the biggest bully and hoping that we can get through lunchtime without somebody taking our lunch”.
For the working people of small island developing states, the stakes are immediate. Small nations do not possess massive standing armies or trillion-dollar treasuries to strong-arm their way through global crises. Instead, they rely on international treaties, maritime law, fair trade rules, and collective security to protect their borders and economies.
Mottley’s insistence that the Caribbean must remain a “zone of peace” reflects the deep desire of Caribbean people to build prosperity through trade, tourism, and cooperation rather than becoming collateral damage in superpower standoffs.
Expanding, Not Merely Preserving, the Global Rules
Crucially, Mottley is not asking the world to blindly defend a broken status quo. Her message resonates with the massive precisely because she demands that the rules-based order be expanded and reformed so that it finally serves all of humanity, not just the victors of 1945.
True multilateralism requires democratizing global governance. Mottley has championed sweeping reforms to the United Nations Security Council—pointing out the injustice that a continent of 54 African nations and a quarter of the world’s countries comprising small island states still lack permanent representation—while backing efforts to curb the paralyzing Security Council veto during mass atrocities.
She has also pushed for an overhaul of the global financial architecture so that climate-vulnerable nations are not trapped in predatory debt cycles while trying to survive hurricanes, rising seas, and droughts they did not cause. Moreover, her call to expand international rules into emerging frontiers like artificial intelligence ensures that powerful corporations and wealthy nations cannot unilaterally write the code that governs everyone else’s future.
The Choice Before Humanity
The message from the massive is unmistakable. A world governed by the Donroe Doctrine offers only instability, subjugation, and the return of imperial arrogance. By contrast, Mia Mottley’s vision of an expanded, inclusive, and enforceable rules-based order offers a path toward shared survival. Rejecting might-makes-right politics and demanding fairness in global institutions is how ordinary people everywhere claim their rightful voice in shaping a peaceful, livable world.
(Garfield L. Angus is a Senior Journalist based in Jamaica.
He is also a Governor General’s Achievement Awards (GGAA) Recipient.)
Email your opinions, letters and commentaries to: letters@caribmagplus.com
